Around December of last year, I started to practice singing on my own. I’d noticed how hard it was for me to get through all of the singing with the synagogue choir over the high holidays, running out of air before the end of almost every musical phrase. I would listen to the opera singer behind me in the bass section in wonder at the control he had over his instrument, and the way he seemed to have enough air to sustain the whole congregation. I’d been to pulmonologists and cardiologists and allergy doctors for all of the possible physical reasons why I struggled to breathe, but for years I’d resisted the idea of focusing on singing itself as a way to improve my breathing patterns, because I knew it would stir up a lot of things I wasn’t ready to deal with. But I finally decided that I was ready to try.
I found an app to start with, called Simply Sing, which gave me some vocal exercises to warm up with and then introduced me to all kinds of music in my vocal range (Alto). I still had a lot of baggage to overcome around my voice: teachers who only wanted me to sing their kind of music; a religious upbringing that said Kol Isha (The voice of a woman) is forbidden for men to hear; voices telling me that if I couldn’t play an instrument (and I really did try) then I had no right to pursue music in any way; and, of course, all of the fears and memories and shame that had attached themselves to different strands of my voice, like interlocking fish hooks.
When my smart phone started to melt down each time I used the app (let’s just say I don’t have the most up to date phone), I switched to cobbling together vocal exercises from YouTube. I spent months trying every different video I could find on YouTube until I found a teacher who didn’t push me too fast or limit me too much, and I gradually started to practice singing with less anxiety, even leaving the windows open, sometimes, instead of trying to hide in my room and muffle the sound. I found song after song that I wanted to sing along with, and for the first time I let myself trust my own judgement about music, instead of assuming that someone would always know better. It wasn’t a smooth, easy process, of course. I hit all of the obstacles I expected to – shame, anxiety, guilt, frustration, failure, hopelessness – but I kept going, because I started to think that I might be able to break through the wall that was stopping me from being comfortable in my own voice, and in my own body.
One of the first surprises in the process was that, even with all of the self-loathing that singing brought up for me (and it really did), certain songs also had a cathartic effect, because the words were able to express something I didn’t know I needed to say, or the music tapped into places in my voice that I couldn’t find on my own. And, maybe even more important to me, I realized that singing along with, say, Otis Redding’s “Sitting on the dock of the bay,” felt like singing with an old friend who really knew me and made me feel less alone.
By the time rehearsals for the choir started again late this past August, I was hopeful that I had made enough of an improvement that someone else might notice. We’d had a preliminary rehearsal in June, where I’d noticed that I wasn’t running out of air the way I used to, and I was looking forward to seeing if I’d made more improvements since then. But something strange happened at the first full choir rehearsal, not only did I realize that I’d forgotten a bunch of the music (especially for songs we don’t sing every year), but about twenty minutes in, I noticed that anything in the middle of my range (between chest voice and head voice – approximately F above middle C up to A, which are pretty much prime territory for an Alto) was scratchy. I felt like I was singing through sand paper. And by the end of the hour and a half, all of those notes were gone, as if they’d been erased. I could still sing below F and above A, but in between it was like someone had pressed the mute button.
I’ve always struggled with the break between registers, because you have to use different muscles to sing the lower notes than the higher notes and coordinating that transition is hard for me, but I had put so much of my energy and time into working on exactly that problem for most of the year, and now the break in my voice was worse.
I went back to my vocal exercises between rehearsals, hoping it was just a temporary problem. Maybe I just needed to warm up more before rehearsal, or do more of the SOVT (Semi‑Occluded Vocal Tract) exercises, like lip trills or blowing bubbles in a glass of water while singing (which is way more fun than it should be). But the same thing happened at the second rehearsal, and the third, and the fourth. I wanted to tell my choir friends that something was wrong and ask for help, but we had so many new singers who were overwhelmed by all of the music they had to learn, and I was embarrassed by how little help I could offer them. I wanted to be one of the confident veterans, calm and reassuring and knowledgeable, and instead I was panicking.
I made it through the high holidays on adrenaline and camaraderie, with the notes in the middle of my voice disappearing earlier and earlier at each service. And then, when I tried to return to my regular vocal exercises in the aftermath, I couldn’t do it. I even stopped doing the breathing exercises that had made such a positive difference from the beginning. It was as if the singing part of me was on strike, as if I was punishing myself, because I was certain this was my fault, that I’d chosen the wrong exercises, or done them the wrong way, and I’d broken my voice forever. And hiding not so far behind that thought was an even worse fear, that no amount of work was ever going to make my voice good enough and I had been wasting my time.
The professional opera singer (whose incredible bass had been one of the inspirations for the whole journey in the first place) had generously offered to give the choir some vocal lessons in January, when we go back to rehearsals, and I took that as permission not to practice at all until then; and it was such a relief. I didn’t have to feel the air hunger of the breathing exercises or feel the shame or frustration or hopelessness in my voice. I could just put it all on the shelf and ignore it for a while. And really, I needed the rest. Looking back, the most obvious explanation for my voice issues is that I had oral surgery in June, and then serious complications that impacted my overall health for months, and I was exhausted and weak by the time the high holidays came around. But I couldn’t believe that explanation, not when the voice in the back of my head kept telling me that I’d done this to myself, by stupidly hoping for more than I deserved.
I still hum all the time, usually forgetting that other people can hear me, but I stopped singing along with friends (on YouTube, not in real life, don’t be silly), and I can’t get myself to work on songwriting, because even reading about music makes my throat hurt. But finally, two months later, I’ve been able to re-start my breathing exercises. It helps that they are silent and I don’t have to worry that people will hear me. Whenever I think I’m ready to go back to YouTube and try even the smallest vocal exercise, the voice in my head tells me I’m hopeless and don’t even have a voice worth developing. I’ve tried to convince myself that this was always going to be a fallow period for me, with so much else going on that needs my attention, but what if I never get back to the path I was on last year? The grief around even the possibility of that loss is profound.
If you haven’t had a chance yet, please check out my novel, Yeshiva Girl, on Amazon. And if you feel called to write a review of the book, on Amazon, or anywhere else, I’d be honored.
Yeshiva Girl is about a Jewish teenager on Long Island, named Isabel, though her father calls her Jezebel. Her father has been accused of inappropriate sexual behavior with one of his students, which he denies, but Izzy implicitly believes it’s true. As a result of his problems, her father sends her to a co-ed Orthodox yeshiva for tenth grade, out of the blue, and Izzy and her mother can’t figure out how to prevent it. At Yeshiva, though, Izzy finds that religious people are much more complicated than she had expected. Some, like her father, may use religion as a place to hide, but others search for and find comfort, and community, and even enlightenment. The question is, what will Izzy find?














